Aston Villa in the Market for a Premier League-Tested Striker
Aston Villa has been advised to sign former Premier League striker Ivan Toney at the end of the season, according to former Aston Villa scout Bryan King. Toney, who is 28 years old, currently plays for Al Ahli in Saudi Arabia, but his return to English football seems to be a topic of interest among Villa’s recruitment team. King believes that Toney, a proven Premier League talent, could significantly bolster Villa’s attacking force, especially given their reliance on Ollie Watkins for goals. While the club has also been linked with other strikers, such as Samu Omorodion and Marcus Rashford, King emphasizes that Toney’s extensive experience and track record in the Premier League make him a compelling choice.
The Case for Ivan Toney
Ivan Toney’s move to Al Ahli at the start of the season has seen him enjoy significant financial benefits, but his time in Saudi Arabia has not been without its drawbacks. King argues that Toney is "wasting his time" in Saudi Arabia, as he is not getting the football satisfaction he craves. Toney’s performance with Brentford in the Premier League is a testament to his ability to thrive in top-tier English football. He is not just a prolific goal scorer but also a creative force, capable of setting up goals for his teammates. This versatility makes him an attractive option for Aston Villa, who need a striker to complement Watkins and add depth to their attack. The opportunity to return to the Premier League and join a club like Aston Villa could be an exciting prospect for Toney, rekindling his passion for the game and providing a new challenge.
Weighing the Options: Omorodion vs. Toney
Aston Villa has been linked with signing 20-year-old Spanish striker Samu Omorodion, who has caught the attention of the club’s scouts and manager Unai Emery. However, King is cautious about spending over £40 million on a player so young. He suggests that if Aston Villa is willing to invest that kind of money, they should consider signing Marcus Rashford, who is a more established and proven talent. Rashford, currently on loan from Manchester United, has the potential to grow further with Aston Villa, and the club has the option to sign him permanently at the end of his loan deal. While Omorodion is a promising talent, the premium price tag for a young player might not be justifiable, especially when there are more experienced options available.
The Rashford Conundrum
Marcus Rashford’s future at Manchester United remains uncertain, and joining Aston Villa on a permanent basis could be an ideal move for the 25-year-old striker. Rashford has struggled for consistent playing time at Old Trafford and is keen to secure a more regular role at a club where he can showcase his talents. Astrid Villa’s style of play under Emery, which emphasizes attacking football, could provide the perfect environment for Rashford to flourish. The club’s option to sign Rashford permanently at the end of his loan deal is a significant factor in their decision-making process. If Aston Villa can secure Rashford’s services, it would not only address their immediate need for a top-class striker but also provide a long-term solution to their attacking woes.
The Financial and Tactical Balance
King’s advice to Aston Villa to consider Toney over Omorodion is rooted in both financial prudence and tactical considerations. Spending over £40 million on a young striker like Omorodion, who is still developing, carries a higher risk. While Toney may not be as young, his experience and proven track record in the Premier League make him a safer and more reliable investment. Toney’s ability to score goals and create opportunities for his teammates aligns well with Aston Villa’s tactical needs. The club needs a striker who can not only find the back of the net but also link up play and provide support to Watkins. Toney’s experience and adaptability could be crucial in helping Aston Villa achieve their goals, whether that is securing a European spot or solidifying their position in the top half of the table.
The Future of Aston Villa’s Attack
The decision on whether to sign Ivan Toney, Samu Omorodion, or Marcus Rashford will have a significant impact on Aston Villa’s attacking lineup in the coming seasons. King’s recommendation to sign Toney is based on his Premier League experience and his potential to make an immediate impact. However, the club’s final decision will depend on various factors, including financial considerations, the players’ current form, and the overall strategic vision of the club. One thing is certain: Aston Villa needs to strengthen their attacking options to reduce their dependence on Ollie Watkins and to compete at a higher level. The summer transfer window will be a critical period for the club, and their choices will shape their future in the Premier League.
