The Struggles of a New Manager
Even a tactical master like Ruben Amorim is finding management at Manchester United to be a daunting challenge. While the club still has a shot at the Europa League, their chances of securing a domestic trophy this season have faded, and their league form has been far from impressive. The pressure is mounting, and Amorim’s focus is now squarely on the upcoming transfer window. With every player effectively auditioning for their future under the new system, the Portuguese manager has to make tough decisions about who fits into his 3-4-3 formation and who doesn’t.
Players Who Fit the Bill
Among the players who seem to be earning their keep, Bruno Fernandes stands out as a testament to adaptability. Despite his polarizing reputation, Fernandes has shown leadership and skill, both for club and country. However, his role in the 3-4-3 system has been a bit of a puzzle. Initially placed as one of the advanced players behind the striker, Fernandes struggled to make the most of his abilities. Recently, Amorim has moved him into a deeper midfield role, where he can dictate the game more effectively. While this shift might slightly reduce his defensive impact, it significantly enhances United’s attacking capabilities. Manuel Ugarte, his partner in the deep midfield, offers the defensive cover and range necessary to complement Fernandes. Ugarte, who previously played under Amorim at Sporting Lisbon, has not dazzled technically but his defensive output makes him a valuable asset. Another player benefiting from a role change is Joshua Zirkzee. Signed as a striker from Bologna, Zirkzee has found more success when moved to a deeper position, where his strength and movement skills allow him to build up attacks and make intelligent runs. His potential in this role makes him a key player for next season, provided he gets the playing time he needs.
Rasmus Hojlund: Potential and Promise
Rasmus Hojlund, the Danish striker signed from Atalanta, is another player who, despite his big price tag, has not yet fully convinced. At just 22 years old, Hojlund has the size, athleticism, and shooting power to be a top-level striker. However, his tendency to come short when he should stay high and his lack of runs to attack space behind the defensive line are concerning. In the 3-4-3 system, where a striker needs to be consistently effective in front of goal, Hojlund’s shortcomings are more pronounced. While he may not be the first-choice striker, his potential and traits make him a player worth keeping, especially if Amorim instructs the recruitment department to find a complementary striker who can allow Hojlund to rest and come in during games when opposition defenses are fatigued.
Those on the Hot Seat
On the other side of the coin, several players are under scrutiny and may not see their futures at Old Trafford. Alejandro Garnacho, an academy graduate and one of the most divisive players among United fans, is facing a tough test. While he has the ability to create goal-scoring chances, his decision-making in attacking positions is often criticized. Garnacho frequently ignores potential passing options to go 1v1, which can lead to deadlocked situations in the final third. Despite his technical skills, his final actions, particularly in shooting, often let him down. Additionally, the club could benefit financially from selling him, making his position in the squad even more uncertain.
Goalkeeping Woes
Andre Onana, the goalkeeper signed from Inter Milan, is another player whose future is in doubt. He came to United with a sterling reputation, particularly for his shot-saving performances in the Champions League. However, his form has been inconsistent, and he has made several high-profile errors. While he has pulled off some spectacular saves, United needs a goalkeeper who can be relied upon consistently. Onana’s mistakes have been too costly, and it seems likely that Amorim will look to move him on this summer.
Defensive Challenges
The defenders, too, are facing scrutiny. Harry Maguire, once a cornerstone of the team, has seen his form decline sharply. Despite getting more consistent game time recently, he continues to make critical errors. His decision-making defensively and his ball-handling skills are no longer at the level required for a top-tier team. With Matthijs de Ligt likely to take up a central role in the back three, Maguire’s future looks increasingly uncertain. Lisandro Martinez, another player who initially seemed like a good signing, is also on the chopping block. While he has shown defensive prowess, his availability through injury has been a significant issue. Moreover, his passive style in possession does not align well with Amorim’s aggressive tactics. The club may need to look for a more robust and versatile central defender to fit the 3-4-3 system effectively.
Conclusion: A Season of Transition
United’s upcoming transfer window will be crucial as the club aims to rebuild and get its finances under control. The period between now and the end of the season is a golden opportunity for players to prove their worth and secure a spot in the squad for next year. Amorim’s 3-4-3 system demands specific roles and attributes, and only those who can adapt and excel will remain. While some players like Bruno Fernandes, Manuel Ugarte, Joshua Zirkzee, and Rasmus Hojlund are stepping up, others like Alejandro Garnacho, Andre Onana, Harry Maguire, and Lisandro Martinez are failing to meet the required standards. The decisions Amorim makes in the coming months will shape the future of Manchester United, and the pressure is on to get it right.
