The New York Islanders’ Defense Dilemma
As the 2025 NHL Trade Deadline approaches, the New York Islanders find themselves in a uniquely challenging position. They have a surplus of defensemen, and while it’s generally advantageous to have depth, managing such a crowded blue line poses significant decisions for the team. The Islanders currently carry eight defensemen, and that number will rise to nine once Mike Reilly returns from injury. However, roster expansion after the trade deadline means the Islanders don’t necessarily have to make tough calls by March 7, 2025. Yet, if they don’t plan on bringing everyone back, it makes sense to explore trade options and try to get value in return.
Key Players and Their Future
At the top of the Islanders’ defensive hierarchy is Alexander Romanov, a 25-year-old restricted free agent (RFA) who has solidified his position as the team’s No. 1 defenseman. Romanov is expected to command a substantial raise this summer, given his performance and potential. Tony DeAngelo, another RFA, has been a perfect fit alongside Romanov, known for his power play prowess and gritty play. His expiring pro-rated deal makes him an attractive trade asset for teams looking to bolster their defense for a playoff run. However, the Islanders would be wise to extend him on a short-term deal if the right offer doesn’t come in.
Struggling Veterans and Trade Possibilities
Veterans Adam Pelech and Ryan Pulock, who carry significant cap hits and have full no-trade clauses, have struggled this season. Both are under long-term deals, making it difficult to move them before the deadline, but the Islanders should still take calls. Pelech’s no-trade clause will change to a modified no-trade clause (16 teams) on July 1, while Pulock’s will follow suit after another year. Despite their struggles, moving these players is a complex task due to their contracts and clauses.
Scott Mayfield: A Potential Trade Chip
One of the more intriguing names on the Isles’ blue line is Scott Mayfield. He has been a healthy scratch for three of the last four games and played a mere 9:04 in his recent return to the lineup. Mayfield, who carries a $3.5 million cap hit for the next five seasons, has a full no-trade clause. However, if he’s not going to see significant ice time, he might be willing to waive his clause to join a contender. Teams like the Toronto Maple Leafs and Tampa Bay Lightning have shown interest, making Mayfield a potential trade chip for the Islanders.
Recent Acquisitions and Their Roles
The Islanders have made several in-season acquisitions, each with their own narrative. Tony DeAngelo, as mentioned, has been a valuable addition, pairing well with Romanov. Adam Boqvist, claimed off waivers from the Florida Panthers, is another offensive-minded defenseman who has shown promise. Boqvist is also a pending RFA and is highly regarded by the coaching staff. However, if the Islanders decide to waive him, they risk losing him to another team.
Depth Options and Future Considerations
Scott Perunovich, acquired from the St. Louis Blues for a conditional fifth-round pick in 2026, has found himself at the bottom of the defensive rotation. After a solid stint when the blue line was injured, he hasn’t played in the past two games. The Islanders face a decision: should they try to trade him or keep him on a cheap deal as a depth option? Another player to consider is Isaiah George, who has shown promise in Bridgeport and could be a candidate for a starting role next season.
Conclusion: Navigating the Trade Deadline
The Islanders are in a tricky situation with their blue line, but they have options. Trading veterans like Mayfield could provide valuable assets, while extending deals to players like DeAngelo and Boqvist can ensure continuity. The team’s management, including general manager Lou Lamoriello and coach Patrick Roy, seems to favor mobile, puck-moving defensemen. Balancing the need for immediate help with long-term planning will be crucial as the trade deadline approaches. Stay tuned for the latest updates and developments in the Islanders’ roster management.
