Consistent Rotation, Uncertain Future
The Atlanta Braves, a franchise known for its reliable starting rotation, face an interesting challenge heading into the 2025 season. While the core of their pitching staff remains solid, the depth and reliability of the rest of the rotation are up in the air. Chris Sale, Reynaldo López, and Spencer Schwellenbach have established themselves as key figures, and Spencer Strider, once he fully recovers from internal brace surgery on his elbow, will rejoin the lineup. However, beyond these top-tier pitchers, the Braves have a mix of experienced and promising Triple-A arms vying for the remaining spots. Grant Holmes, Ian Anderson, A.J. Smith-Shawver, and Bryce Elder are among the contenders, each bringing their own strengths and uncertainties to the table.
Seeking Depth and Stability
As the Braves prepare for the upcoming season, the need for a consistent and reliable rotation cannot be overstated. President of baseball operations Alex Anthopoulos is actively exploring options to bolster the starting lineup. One potential trade target is San Diego Padres star Dylan Cease, a Georgia native and a formidable presence on the mound with over 200 strikeouts in each of the last four seasons. Cease would be an ideal addition, but the trade cost might be prohibitive for just one year of guaranteed control. This has led to discussions about more affordable alternatives that could provide the stability the Braves need.
Considering the Options
FanSided’s Austin Owens recently suggested that former St. Louis Cardinals starter Kyle Gibson could be a low-cost alternative to Cease. Gibson, while not a front-of-the-rotation ace, has a track record of delivering consistent innings. In 30 starts last season, he went 8-8 with a 4.24 ERA, making him a solid choice for the back end of the rotation. At 37 years old, Gibson made $13 million last season with St. Louis and is likely available for a similar price this year. The key advantage of acquiring Gibson is the reduced trade cost compared to Cease, as the Braves wouldn’t have to give up top prospects to land him. This makes him an attractive option for a team that needs to balance immediate needs with long-term sustainability.
Balancing Needs and Resources
The decision to pursue Gibson or stick with the current roster will depend on Anthopoulos’s assessment of the team’s immediate and long-term needs. While Gibson might not generate the same fan excitement as a high-profile star like Cease, he offers valuable innings and experience that can help bridge the gap while the younger pitchers continue to develop. This is particularly important while Strider is still on the mend from his elbow surgery. The Braves need to ensure they have a reliable rotation to compete in the highly competitive National League East, and Gibson could provide the stability they need without breaking the bank.
Weighing the Pros and Cons
Gibson’s experience and consistency make him a solid fit for the Braves, but there are also concerns to consider. At 37, his long-term durability and effectiveness may be in question, and the Braves will need to weigh the risks against the benefits. Additionally, the team’s development pipeline is strong, and giving young pitchers like Holmes and Anderson more opportunities could help them mature and become reliable starters in the future. Anthopoulos will need to strike a balance between immediate needs and the long-term development of the team’s young talent.
Looking Ahead
In conclusion, the Atlanta Braves are at a crossroads as they prepare for the 2025 season. While they have a strong core of starting pitchers, the depth and reliability of their rotation are uncertain. Trading for a cost-effective option like Kyle Gibson could provide the stability and consistency they need while allowing the younger pitchers to develop. Anthopoulos will need to carefully consider the team’s immediate and long-term needs to make the best decision for the Braves. The upcoming season will be a test of the team’s adaptability and the strength of their pitching depth.
