An Unfulfilled Promise: Najee Harris’s Free Agency
The Pittsburgh Steelers are facing a pivotal decision this offseason regarding their offensive lineup, particularly with the potential replacement of starting running back Najee Harris. Once a promising first-round pick, Harris burst onto the scene during his rookie year, but his subsequent performances over the next three years failed to match that initial success. In response, the Steelers declined Harris’s fifth-year option, positioning him for free agency. Harris’s diminishing production and lack of standout performances suggest that the team is wise to reconsider their investment in him. Instead, they should focus on finding a more cost-effective option to pair with Jaylen Warren, who has shown potential as a backup.
Potential Interest in Nick Chubb
One player who has caught the Steelers’ attention is Nick Chubb, currently with the Cleveland Browns. According to Jeff Hathhorn of 93.7 The Fan, Pittsburgh is showing interest in Chubb and has engaged in preliminary discussions. "I’ll throw out a name of someone I know they’re interested in, and at least talking to. The medicals would have to play out, and obviously, it would be a decision, but Nick Chubb is someone they would consider," Hathhorn shared. Chubb, a four-time Pro Bowler, was once one of the top running backs in the NFL, but his career has faced significant setbacks due to injuries. A one-year "prove-it" deal worth around $3.2 million, as estimated by Spotrac, might be attractive given his proven track record and the lower financial commitment.
Chubb’s Injury History and Performance Decline
Chubb’s 2023 season was cut short by a major knee injury, and he returned in 2024 to appear in just eight games before suffering a broken foot in Week 15. Even when he was on the field, Chubb’s form was not as explosive as it once was, a trend that is especially concerning as he approaches his 30th birthday. His lackluster performance can be partly attributed to the challenging circumstances surrounding his return from a serious knee injury and the subpar support system he had in Cleveland. Despite these factors, the Steelers should be cautious about assuming his struggles can be reversed, as the team’s offense is in dire need of an injection of dynamism.
The Need for Explosiveness
Pittsburgh’s offense has been criticized for its lack of excitement and effectiveness, and signing Chubb may not address these core issues. The Steelers require a running back who can bring a new level of explosiveness and unpredictability to the game. Chubb’s recent injury history and diminished form make him a risky and potentially inadequate candidate for this role. While the one-year deal mitigates some financial risk, the team should prioritize finding a player who can genuinely elevate the offense’s performance and create opportunities for big plays.
Strategic Considerations for the Steelers
If the Steelers do opt to sign Chubb, it should be on the condition that they are fully committed to drafting a running back in the 2025 NFL Draft. Chubb’s situation is far from stable, and his ability to provide the necessary boost to Pittsburgh’s ground game remains uncertain. A one-year contract would allow the team to assess his current capabilities while keeping their options open for the future. However, this move should not be seen as a long-term solution. The Steelers must remain vigilant and continue to explore other avenues to strengthen their offensive lineup.
The Bottom Line on Chubb
In summary, while Nick Chubb’s name has been floated as a potential replacement for Najee Harris, the Steelers should proceed with caution. Chubb’s injury history and decline in performance suggest that he may not be the explosive running back the team needs to revitalize their offense. The allure of a relatively low-cost one-year deal is understandable, but it would be prudent for the Steelers to focus on younger, more dynamic options. Head coach Mike Tomlin should avoid the temptation of nostalgia and instead prioritize finding a player who can make a significant and immediate impact on the field.
