Introduction
The 2025 NFL Draft is shaping up to be one of the most intriguing in recent memory, and Yahoo Sports draft experts Nate Tice and Charles McDonald have compiled their first consensus big board of the top 50 prospects. Both experts have already delivered their individual post-combine rankings, but now they’ve joined forces to provide a combined evaluation. Here’s a deeper look at the top six players who could make a significant impact in the NFL.
1. Travis Hunter, CB/WR, Colorado
Travis Hunter’s placement at the top of the big board is a testament to his unique versatility and athleticism. Not only did he win the Heisman Trophy, but he also captured the Bednarik Award for the best defensive player and the Biletnikoff Award for the best wide receiver in college football. This rarity makes him a legitimate first-round prospect at both positions. Hunter’s exceptional ball skills and overall athleticism are evident, and he has already expressed his desire to play both ways in the NFL, a challenging but not impossible feat. While he might be slightly more pro-ready as a cornerback, where his instincts and movement can disrupt passing games, his potential as a wide receiver is equally exciting. The term "generational" is often overused, but it genuinely applies to Hunter, who has already demonstrated extraordinary talents. — CM
2. Abdul Carter, Edge, Penn State
Penn State linebacker Abdul Carter, now wearing the storied No. 11 jersey, is often compared to Micah Parsons, a lofty and unfair benchmark. However, Carter’s performance and potential come close to that standard. He is a dynamic pass rusher with the ability to bend around corners and maintain balance, despite contorting his body. Carter’s combination of length, quick-twitch athleticism, and play strength gives him the upside of an elite edge defender, capable of double-digit sacks in the NFL. Though he needs to improve his run discipline and sometimes relies too much on knifing inside, his medical evaluations have revealed a stress fracture in his foot that will need monitoring. Despite these concerns, Carter’s ability to bring energy and disrupt the game is undeniable, and he even has prior experience as an off-ball linebacker and interior pass rusher. — NT
3. Will Johnson, CB, Michigan
Will Johnson’s college career at Michigan, while marred by injuries in his final season, showcased his potential to be a dominant cornerback. Johnson was a key player for the national-title-winning Wolverines defense, and his best performances, particularly during his sophomore year, draw comparisons to Broncos cornerback Patrick Surtain II. Johnson’s ability to match up against top wide receivers and his calm, quick footwork make him an attractive prospect. His interview performance will be crucial, but Johnson’s potential to be an immediate eraser on the defensive side is why he ranks highly. — CM
4. Ashton Jeanty, RB, Boise State
Ashton Jeanty, a running back from Boise State, is a standout in this draft class. Built like a tank, Jeanty is incredibly tough to bring down and consistently breaks tackles with ease. He demonstrated his ability to handle a heavy workload and perform well against stronger opponents. Jeanty’s running style is reminiscent of veteran NFL backs, and his versatility in both the running and passing game makes him a valuable asset. If he can continue to produce at this level in the NFL, Jeanty will be a sweet addition to any offense. — CM
5. Will Campbell, OT/OG, LSU
Will Campbell is a smooth and technically proficient offensive lineman who seldom gets out of position. His excellent hand usage and quick footwork allow him to recover against defensive counters effectively. LSU often relies on Campbell to handle one-on-one matchups in drop-back situations, which will serve him well at the next level. Despite his arm length being slightly below the NFL average for tackles, Campbell’s overall athleticism and technique can mitigate this deficiency. He is also a smart player, often calling out blitzes and defensive movements. Whether he stays at tackle or moves to guard, Campbell has the potential to be a significant contributor on the offensive line. — NT
6. Tetairoa McMillan, WR, Arizona
Tetairoa McMillan, a wide receiver from Arizona, is a true monster on the outside. With excellent hands and ball skills, he consistently creates yards after the catch due to his strength and balance. His volleyball and basketball background contribute to his comfort in extending for difficult throws and maintaining speed upon catching the ball. McMillan’s route running is polished, allowing him to create separation at intermediate levels and even from the slot. While he may lack elite long speed, his frame and ball skills make him a consistent vertical threat. McMillan’s versatility and ability to contribute immediately in various roles make him a highly coveted prospect. — NT
7. Armand Membou, OT, Missouri
Armand Membou, the right tackle for Missouri, has a unique build but possesses the length, strength, and athleticism to excel at the position. His performance at the NFL combine, where he recorded a 4.91 40-yard dash and reached a top speed of 20.28 miles per hour, was exceptional, especially given his size of 332 pounds. Membou’s ability to move in space and reach outside defenders on zone runs has been a significant asset for Missouri. He shows the potential to handle the left tackle position if necessary and has the movement ability and length to be a valuable asset on the interior as well. Despite needing refinement in his technique and hand placement, Membou’s youth and natural talents make him an ascending prospect with a lot of upside. — NT
8. Mason Graham, DT, Michigan
Mason Graham’s college career at Michigan was marred by injuries, but when he was on the field, he was a game-changer. His combination of speed, power, and technique made him a force on the interior of the defensive line. In 2023, Graham’s performances were so dominant that he was a potential first overall pick. While he may not reach those heights in the 2025 draft, his ability to penetrate and disrupt plays remains a valuable asset. Graham’s versatility and potential to impact the game in multiple ways make him a strong prospect for any team looking to bolster their defensive front. — CM
Conclusion
This consensus big board offers a glimpse into the exceptional talents and potential of the 2025 NFL Draft class. From the versatile Travis Hunter to the powerful Mason Graham, these prospects bring a mix of skills that could significantly impact their future teams. As the draft cycle progresses, more evaluations and insights will be crucial, but these initial rankings provide a solid foundation for understanding the top prospects. Teams will have to weigh the strengths and weaknesses of each player carefully to find the best fit for their needs. — NT
