The Giants’ Crucial Decision: Third Overall Pick in the 2025 Draft
After an abysmal 3-14 season in 2024, the New York Giants find themselves holding the third overall pick in the 2025 NFL Draft. The stakes are incredibly high, with the organization under immense pressure to make the right move and inject new life into a struggling franchise. Head Coach Brian Daboll and General Manager Joe Schoen are on the hot seat, and the Giants’ future hinges on their ability to make a significant upgrade at the most critical position in football: quarterback.
Analyst Predictions: A Focus on Quarterback
Several football experts have weighed in on the Giants’ potential moves, consistently pointing to the quarterback position as the key area of focus. SNY’s Connor Hughes suggests that the Giants could trade up to the No. 2 pick with the Cleveland Browns to select Colorado’s Shedeur Sanders. Hughes notes that the Browns would likely drive up the price for this trade, but the Giants might be willing to overpay given the importance of finding a franchise quarterback.
Shedeur Sanders: A Potential Game-Changer
CBS Sports’ Josh Edwards and Fox Sports’ Joel Klatt both advocate for the selection of Shedeur Sanders, albeit through different routes. Edwards believes that Sanders is the right choice to bring excitement and much-needed improvement to the Giants. Klatt, on the other hand, envisions a more dramatic move, suggesting that the Giants could trade up to the No. 1 pick with the Tennessee Titans. Klatt argues that Sanders is the clear-cut best quarterback in the draft and that a trade with the Titans would be beneficial for both parties. The Giants have reportedly established a strong relationship with Sanders, and the mutual interest could make this a perfect fit.
Cam Ward: A Different Path
ESPN’s Field Yates and The Athletic’s Charolette Carroll both favor Miami’s Cam Ward as the Giants’ top target. Yates posits that the Giants and Raiders are the teams most in need of a quarterback upgrade and suggests that Ward could be the first signal-caller off the board. Ward’s impressive performance in his lone season at Miami, where he threw for 39 touchdowns and 4,313 yards, makes him a highly attractive prospect. While he needs to refine his footwork and decision-making, Ward’s potential is undeniable.
High Upside and High Stakes
Pro Football and Sports Network’s Brentley Weissman also endorses Ward, emphasizing his big arm and ability to find open receivers at all levels of the field. Weissman believes that Ward has the highest upside among the quarterbacks in this year’s class and that his rookie performance could be crucial for Daboll and Schoen’s job security. The Giants’ need for a new quarterback is dire, and the pressure to choose the right player is immense.
The Decision’s Impact on the Organization
The Giants’ decision in the 2025 NFL Draft will have far-reaching consequences. A successful pick could mark the beginning of a new era of success for the franchise, while a misstep could further exacerbate the team’s struggles. Both Shedeur Sanders and Cam Ward present compelling options, each with unique strengths and potential. As the draft approaches, the Giants must carefully weigh their options and make a choice that will define their future for years to come. The pressure is on, and the entire NFL will be watching.
